HUMANISTIC EDUCATION ONLINE: CAN IT BE IMPLEMENTED?
HUMANISTIC EDUCATION ONLINE: CAN IT BE IMPLEMENTED?
Muhamad Aditya Hidayah / 20104060025
e-mail : madityahidayah@gmail.com
Chemistry Education, Sunan Kalijaga State Islamic University
Introduction
Education is needed by humans, as social beings, to interact with one another, and it is meant to be the most enjoyable place for people (learners) to grow and develop according to the potential they have, as provision for life in society. Since the Covid-19 outbreak was declared a pandemic, and health protocols were enforced in many countries that reduced direct physical contact, many institutions have had to adjust to these conditions. Educational institutions are among those that had to adjust by moving teaching and learning activities to an online system (daring, "in the network") without direct face-to-face contact.
Online learning has become an increasingly common alternative in the midst of the pandemic. In Indonesia, the online learning system was established with the issuance of Circular Letter Number 4 of 2020 on the Implementation of Education Policy in the Emergency Period of the Spread of Covid-19 on 24 March 2020. The transition from the conventional learning system to online learning required learners, educators, and other elements of learning to adapt to the change as quickly as possible. The change that occurred is that humanistic education, which was initially carried out conventionally, had to be carried out online.
Humanistic education is an education system that focuses on human potential, helping people seek and discover the abilities they have and develop those abilities (Riyanton, 2017). Humanistic education views learners as human beings with different potentials and characteristics, with the concept of respecting human dignity in order to create a learning environment that frees learners from great competition, strict discipline, and fear of failure. Thus, if humanistic education is effective when carried out face to face (in direct meetings), can it be implemented in the online learning system in this pandemic era?
Effective Humanistic Education
Humanistic education in Indonesia was conceived long ago by the Father of Indonesian Education, Ki Hajar Dewantara, in his teaching “Ing Ngarso Sung Tulodo, Ing Madyo Mangun Karso, Tut Wuri Handayani (At the front, set an example; in the middle, build spirit; and from behind, give encouragement)”. When related to the concept of humanistic education, this is consistent with the idea that a person who can develop fully in all aspects of their humanity will be able to respect the humanity of every person.
In education, the key to success is that learners have a balance between the potential they have and a conducive environment. This is because humans have a tendency to do good, but if they do not receive support from the environment, that potential will turn into negative potential. Therefore, to create humanistic education to the fullest, attention must be paid to the balance between these two aspects, namely the internal and external aspects of the human being.
The internal aspect of humanistic education is the learner, while one of the external aspects is the educator. The educator is the most important aspect of education. Without educators, education cannot run, so educators are the key figures for the continuity of education.
According to Riyanto (2017), good and effective humanistic education is interpreted as education aimed at the interests of all components of education, oriented not only towards the humanity of learners but also towards educators. Thus, the interests of both learners and educators are respected and honoured.
The humanism of learners is certainly different from the humanism of educators. For learners, it means not being subjected to unfair judgement and being free to develop talents and potential, while also having to respect educators. For educators, it means being not only a giver of instructions but also a facilitator in teaching, while also having to respect learners.
The Transition of Conventional Humanistic Education to Online: Can It Be Implemented?
Before discussing the implementation of humanistic education carried out online in this pandemic era, it is worth examining whether conventional humanistic education has run optimally or not. In fact, humanistic education itself has not been perfectly realised in many educational institutions in Indonesia, as evidenced by the continuing cases of violence by educators against learners. Based on the research results of Tamsil (2017) among 200 learner respondents, the incidents were as follows: verbal violence in 60 (30.3%) incidents, violence by labelling learners in 12 (6.1%) incidents, violence by ignoring students in 36 (18.18 %) incidents, violence using objects in 29 (14.65%), violence by intimidation in 33 (16.67%) incidents, and physical violence in 28 (14.14%).
Besides violence, another equally important matter is the way educators teach. The education system in Indonesia demands that learners master all the subjects given. Of course, this can cause learners' talents and potential in certain fields to fade, because they cannot develop as each learner wishes, so learners tend to chase academic grades without thinking about their talents and potential.
A misunderstanding of the way of thinking among conventional educators, who treat learners as objects of education who must follow the blueprint the educators want, is a determining cause of why the concept of humanistic education is applied so far from its ideal. This is the main reason learners weaken the role of educators as people who are “emulated and heeded”. Because of this, cases of harassment of and rebellion against educators are increasing; the main factor is the stress students experience from learning methods and the lack of appreciation for learners. This proves that conventional humanistic education in Indonesia still does not run well, because the two most important aspects of humanistic education (educators and learners) have not yet received humanism in full. So what about the application of humanistic education in the pandemic era carried out online; can it be realised?
The implementation of humanistic education carried out online is not as smooth as hoped. Many factors hinder the implementation process, including the following:
1. Lack of Direct Supervision of Learners' Personality and Character by Educators
Online learning obstructs the educator's task of approaching learners, so assessing and knowing character, personality, and potential becomes difficult. This is of course disadvantageous for educators because they will find it hard to apply humanistic education in order to develop the talents and potential of each learner.
2. Suboptimal Delivery of Material and a Tendency to Overemphasise Assignments
Suboptimal delivery of material causes learners to understand the material presented by educators less well. Therefore, many learners feel that online learning only makes them dizzy and they do not follow lessons wholeheartedly. Learning is suboptimal because educators only emphasise giving assignments. As a result, learners feel tired because of the piling-up assignments. This is proven by the survey results of the Indonesian Child Protection Commission (KPAI) Commissioner for Education, Retno Listyari (2020), which stated that out of a total of 1,700 respondents, 77.8% complained that educators gave assignments continuously. Meanwhile, 37.1% of respondents complained about the short time for completing them, which resulted in lack of rest and exhaustion. Of course, this becomes an obstacle to implementing humanistic education, because learners' psychological freedom in learning is disturbed and they become pressured.
3. Uneven Distribution of Facilities Supporting Online Learning Across All Regions of Indonesia
In terms of facilities, online learning has obstacles that must be faced. According to Ericha (2020), online learning has a weakness in facilities in the use of the internet network, which requires adequate infrastructure. This is of course needed so that all regions are reached by the internet and online learning can be carried out evenly. However, in reality, many remote areas still have difficulty accessing the internet. Based on data from the Central Statistics Agency (Badan Pusat Statistik) for 2019, the average internet penetration rate in rural areas is 51.91%, which shows low network (signal) quality and affects online learning.
Besides the internet, supporting equipment is of course also very much needed. The availability of gadgets, laptops, or computers is still uneven and does not reach remote villages, and for learners with economic limitations, owning a device to support learning is difficult. If the facilities are not met, the implementation of humanistic education will be hindered. This is because the bridge connecting educators and learners online will be cut off without facilities.
4. Insufficient Understanding of Technology Use by Learners (Parents)
Not all learners understand how to use the technology of the online learning system, especially learners at the primary level. Here the role of parents is very much needed, but not all parents of learners understand technology. This can of course become an obstacle to the continuity of online learning. Therefore, educators need to hold outreach so that accompanying parents can understand the technology used in online learning.
Given the various obstacles faced, the implementation of online humanistic education will be hard to achieve without solutions. Although it is not as effective as conventional implementation (direct face-to-face), if the obstacles are given solutions, humanistic education online can still be implemented. Some solutions that can be carried out are as follows:
- Educators deliver material that is easy to understand and in depth, minimising the giving of assignments and orienting towards learners' understanding.
- Character formation can be developed and monitored through activities such as greetings, facial expressions, enthusiasm, greeting one another, educational interaction, activeness, self-confidence, and integrity.
- Learners in online learning must have strong intention and determination, maximum effort, sportsmanship and teamwork, and constantly pray.
- For educators to be able to provide character education, they need to pay attention to integrating subject material, integrating the process, integrating the choice of teaching materials, and integrating the choice of supporting media.
- The relevant government needs to improve facilities supporting online learning, so that problems with the internet network, signal, and required equipment (gadgets, laptops or computers) can be overcome. Thus, online learning can be received by learners throughout Indonesia.
- Educators should provide outreach on the use of online learning technology so that the learning system can run optimally.
Thus, it is hoped that humanistic education can be implemented online in this pandemic era if those solutions can be realised. As a result, online humanistic education can be carried out effectively, even if not as effectively as conventional humanistic education.
Conclusion
This pandemic period pushes us to adapt the learning process to a new system. Both educators and learners also adapt to online learning. However, humanistic education still needs to be applied, so that Indonesia's golden generation, with each person's unique potential, can be born and together advance Indonesia
All the implications presented are an orientation for implementing humanistic education in the pandemic era carried out online. Hopefully, with cooperation from educators, learners, the government, and other parties, humanistic education in online learning can be applied, so that the values and principles of humanistic education are not lost and continue to be carried on in the midst of this Covid-19 pandemic.
References
[BPS]. Badan Pusat Statistik Indonesia. 2019. Penetrasi Internet diberbagai Daerah Indonesia.
Ericha, W.P. Dampak Covid-19 Terhadap Kegiatan Penbelajaran Online di sebuah Perguruan Tinggi Kristen Indonesia. Jurnal Perspektif Pendidikan. 34 (1) : 1-8.
Maria Fatima Bona. 2020. Satu Bulan Belajar Online, 72,8% Siswa Mengeluh Penumpukan Tugas. https://www.beritasatu.com/elvira-anna-siahaan/nasional/625917/satu-bulan-belajar-online-728-siswa-mengeluh-penumpukan-tugas. Diakses tanggal 20 September 2020.
Menteri Pendidikan dan Kebudayaan RI SE No. 4 Tahun 2020 Tentang Pelaksanaan Kebijakan Pendidikan dalam Masa Darurat Penyebaran Covid-19.
Paing, Reneldus M. 2020. Perkuliahan Daring: Solusi atau Pelarian?. Depok : Universitas Sanata Dharma.
Pramono. 2016. Konsep Pendidikan Humanis H.A.R Tilaar dan Relevansinya dengan Pendidikan Agama Islam. Skripsi. UIN Sunan Kalijaga.
Riyanton, M. 2017. Pendidikan Humanisme dan Implementasinya dalam pembelajaran Bahsa Indonesia. Jurnal.Universitas Jendral Soedirman.
Rosyada, Dede. 2004. Paradigma Pendidikan Demokratis. Jakarta: Kencana.
Tamsil, M. 2017. Tindakan Kekerasan Guru Terhadap Siswa dalaam Interaksi Belajar Mengajar. Jurnal Pendidikan. 2 (1) : 72-76.
Comments (0)
No comments yet.